Compare the pair. Two lines of Angus steers. Same sale, same region. Yet Vendor A sold at auction for $150 over reserve, and Vendor B sold post auction, $75 under reserve.
Vendor A started below the comparable market and let auction competition drive the price, selling for $50 more than Vendor B. Vendor B started at the comparable market price, leaving no room for multiple bidders to compete, and had to negotiate under their reserve post auction.
It’s the same pattern APlus News found earlier this month in “Your reserve isn’t last week’s sold price”: cattle sold at auction started from lower reserves than cattle sold post auction yet sold for $159 a head more.
Earlier in the year, two Northern Tasmanian vendors offered weaned Angus steers in the same AuctionsPlus sale, from properties about an hour apart.
Vendor A offered eight-month-old, weaned Angus steers averaging 240kg at delivery. Vendor B offered a larger run of five-to-seven-month steers averaging 246kg.
Each line had its own premium factors. One was the more even line on weight, while the other carried well-regarded bloodlines. Either way, they were similar steers from a similar area, competing for the same pool of buyers.
Both vendors set their start price just under their reserve. The difference was where they set them against the comparable market.
Vendor A: room to compete
Vendor A started at $1,170 with a reserve of $1,200, 11–13% under what similar Tasmanian steers were making in the weeks leading up, with the previous week selling at $1,350.
Two bidders competed for the steers, placing 18 bids between them. They sold at auction for $1,350, $150 over reserve and right on last week’s sold price. In total, that’s $6,000 more than the vendor had set as their minimum.
Vendor B: starting at the market
Vendor B started at $1,340 with a reserve of $1,375, right on what similar steers had made the week before.
A single bidder bid at $1,350, $25 short of the reserve, and with no one else competing, the run passed in. Left to negotiate with that one party, the vendor settled at $1,300 post auction: $75 under reserve and $40 under their own start price. Across 142 head, that’s $10,650 less than the vendor had set as their reserve.
Figure 1: Start, reserve, sale price for each vendor, against comparable TAS steer sold price. Source: AuctionsPlus
Both lines were up for auction at the same time, but Vendor B’s steers were never the cheaper option. The buyer who missed out on Vendor A stopped bidding at $1,340, exactly where Vendor B started. On the day, the market was $1,340 to $1,350/head and Vendor A got there through competition while Vendor B asked buyers to start there.
Starting close to the reserve works, as long as both sit below the comparable market. A start or a reserve at last week's sold price isn't a starting point. It's the finish line.
Before the next listing, ask: "What's the lowest price I'd accept for these cattle today?" Set the reserve there, start just under it, and let the buyers in the auction do the rest.
AuctionsPlus gives you the data to do it: