Our recent analysis of Eastern Young Cattle Indicator (EYCI) volatility generated plenty of interest, particularly around whether the larger price swings experienced in recent years represent a genuine increase in volatility or simply reflect higher cattle prices.
The findings confirmed that young cattle prices have become considerably more volatile since 2020, although current volatility remains below the historical extremes of the 1970s and early 1980s.
One of the more common questions following that article was whether the same trends were evident across other livestock categories.
Are heavy steer prices experiencing similar levels of volatility to young cattle? What about trade lamb and mutton? Have sheepmeat markets also become more volatile, or does their longer history tell a different story?
To answer these questions, Episode 3 extended the original analysis to include heavy steers, trade lamb and mutton, using monthly inflation-adjusted prices dating back to January 1953.
As with the original EYCI analysis, volatility was measured using monthly percentage price changes rather than absolute cents-per-kilogram movements. This removes much of the distortion associated with comparing prices at substantially different levels.
The first interesting finding is that volatility has increased across all four livestock categories since 2020, although the magnitude of those increases varies considerably.
Compared with the 2010–2019 period, young cattle recorded the largest increase in monthly price volatility, rising 61pc from 4.9pc to 7.9pc during 2020–2025.
Heavy steer volatility also increased substantially, rising 41pc from 4.2pc to 6.0pc.
The increase was less pronounced across sheepmeat markets. Mutton volatility rose 29pc, from 9.8pc to 12.7pc, while trade lamb volatility increased just 11pc, from 6.8pc to 7.5pc.
The results suggest that the recent increase in livestock price volatility has been particularly concentrated in cattle markets.
The difference between young cattle and heavy steer volatility is particularly revealing.
Both categories are exposed to the same broad cattle market cycle, yet young cattle prices have experienced considerably greater percentage fluctuations in recent years.
One possible explanation is the influence of restocker competition on young cattle prices, potentially due to more extreme rainfall variation.
The transition from drought-induced herd liquidation to widespread rebuilding can generate substantial changes in demand for younger cattle. As seasonal conditions improve, restocker competition can intensify rapidly, before easing again as rebuilding activity slows.
Heavy steer prices, by comparison, are more closely associated with finished cattle demand and processor competition, potentially providing a less volatile pricing environment.
This may help explain why the extraordinary cattle cycle between 2020 and 2023 generated a more pronounced volatility response in the EYCI than heavy steer prices.
Nevertheless, neither category is experiencing record volatility.
The latest three-year rolling volatility measure for young cattle sits at 9.2pc, below the historical peak of 11.7pc recorded in 1980. Heavy steer volatility currently sits at 6.4pc, compared with its historical peak of 10.8pc in 1976.
Perhaps the most surprising finding from the expanded analysis is just how volatile sheepmeat prices have been historically, particularly mutton.
Current three-year rolling volatility sits at 16.1pc for mutton and 8.1pc for trade lamb, compared with historical peaks of 41.4pc and 18.9pc respectively during the early 1990s.
Between 1980 and 1999, monthly mutton price volatility averaged 27.5pc, compared with 13.8pc for trade lamb, 5.5pc for young cattle and 5.0pc for heavy steers.
Mutton was therefore around five times more volatile than cattle during this period.
The frequency of substantial monthly price movements reinforces the finding.
During the 1980s and 1990s, almost half of all months recorded mutton price movements exceeding 10pc in either direction. For trade lamb, the equivalent figure was 37.5pc.
Since 2020, those proportions have eased to 33.3pc for mutton and 18.1pc for trade lamb.
Historically low mutton prices contributed to some of the extreme percentage fluctuations, with relatively small absolute movements producing substantial proportional changes.
Despite the recent increase in sheepmeat volatility, both categories remain well below their historical peaks.
The expanded analysis reinforces an important finding from our original EYCI investigation.
Australian livestock price volatility generally declined over several decades leading into 2020, before increasing again during the most recent market cycle.
What has changed is the relative volatility between livestock categories.
Sheepmeat markets, particularly mutton, have historically experienced substantially greater percentage price fluctuations than cattle. That gap has narrowed considerably, with young cattle volatility during 2020–2025 exceeding trade lamb volatility.
Whether this represents a structural change in livestock markets or simply reflects an unusually pronounced cattle cycle remains uncertain.
The key finding is that while all four livestock categories have become more volatile since 2020, cattle prices have experienced the largest relative increase, particularly young cattle.
Mutton remains the most volatile livestock category, but the historical evidence suggests that today's sheepmeat market is considerably less turbulent than it was during much of the 1980s and 1990s.
For those wondering whether the larger price swings being experienced across livestock markets are unprecedented, the answer is fairly straightforward.
Volatility has certainly increased recently, but history shows Australian livestock markets have been through considerably more volatile periods before.
Matt Dalgleish is a director of Episode3.net and co-host of the Agwatchers podcast.